Maccabbee Bushcraft & Outdoor Gear
  • Home
  • Sales
  • Products
    • Packs
    • Basecamp >
      • Sleep
      • Cordage
      • Camp Storage
    • Knives & Cutting Tools >
      • Axes
      • Saws
      • Wood Carving
      • Multi-Tool
    • Fire & Light >
      • Stoves
    • Coffee
    • Food & Cookware
    • Water & Hydration
    • Navigation
    • Rappelling
    • Hygiene
    • First Aid >
      • First Aid Video Resources
    • Foraging >
      • Herbal Courses
    • Off The Grid
    • Bushcraft Books/DVD's
    • Apparel
  • Bushcraft Education
    • Exploring The Grand Syllabus >
      • My Wilderness Experience Log Book
    • Why Write A Wilderness Experience Log Book
    • Bushcraft Tutorials >
      • Wood Working Tutorials
      • Navigation Tutorials
      • Foraging Tutorials
      • Cooking Tutorials
    • Fauna
    • Trees >
      • Food Sources
      • Medicinal Properties
      • Fuel/Construction
    • Wild Edibles >
      • Wild Edible List
      • Medicinal Plants >
        • Medicinal Blog
      • Edible Mushrooms
      • Mushroom Poisoning Facts
  • Blog
  • Policies
  • About Us
    • Contact

To learn is our duty
to pass on what we have learned
​is our oBligation

social programing

3/14/2019

1 Comment

 
Picture
If you are like me you probably don't even take anything you watch serious. And why? Well unfortunately there is an agenda in much of anything media produced, and well those who desire to pollute their desired agenda upon the masses will use their money to do it at all cost. Sean Penn who both directed and produced this horrible version of the story of Christopher McCandless  whose sad life ended do to starvation, desired to pervert the idea that eating wild edibles was the real cause of his young ended life. And well according to this lame movie the bad guy of the story was Mr. Wild Sweet Pea (Hedysarum mackenzii). Why oh why does the public have to continually get feed garbage instead of the truth? The whole focal point is they want to demonize wild edibles so as to no allow people to think "their is gold to be found in them woods."

So how did this all come about? Well according to Wikipedia "On July 30, McCandless wrote a journal entry which read, "Extremely Weak. Fault Of Pot[ato] Seed" Based on this entry, Krakauer hypothesized that McCandless had been eating what he thought was the roots of an edible plant, Hedysarum alpinum, commonly known as wild Eskimo potato, which are sweet and nourishing in the spring but later become too tough to eat. When this happened, McCandless may have attempted to eat the seeds instead. Krakauer first speculated that the seeds were actually from Hedysarum mackenzii, or wild sweet pea, instead of the Eskimo Potato, which contained a poisonous alkaliod, possibly swainsonine (the toxic chemical in locoweed) or something similar. In addition to neurological symptoms, such as weakness and loss of coordination, the poison causes starvation by blocking nutrient metabolism in the body." And well this false idea went raging mad all over thanks to his stupid 1996 book "Into the Wild" which reported this non-factual idea.

But special thanks to Edward M. Treadwell and Thomas P. Clausen who did a study at the Ethnobotany Research and Applications and wrote in their research their wonderful findings, which finally discredited the stupid lie Krakauer who began his version in 1996 and Sean Penn promoted his version in 2007 was finally laid to rest in 2008.

Ethnobotany Research and Applications

Hedysarum mackenzii (wild sweet pea, bear root) is widely regarded as toxic and warnings about confusing it with its edible cousin H. alpinum (Eskimo potato) abound. To find the chemical basis for this claim, we performed an exhaustive comparison of the secondary chemistry between the two plants as well as a search for nitrogen containing metabolites (alkaloids) in both species. No chemical basis for toxicity could be found. These results were consistent with a subsequent cytotoxic assay performed on an extract of H. mackenzii. Finally, a critical examination of the literature could find no credible evidence that H. mackenzii is toxic in spite of these widespread rumors.
Picture
What is even sadder is how Sean Penn went about this by falsifying and completely altering reality as he portrayed to the public a book entry which never actually existed in the first place. And we can give thanks to Samuel Thayer for this information as he records in his book Natures Garden pg 43-60

Natures Garden By Samuel Thayer

​Tanaina Plantlore (Kari 1987)

The book live found in the movie Into the Wild "The lateral veins, nearly invisible on leaflets of wild sweet pea plants poisonous seedlings. If ingested symptoms include partial motor paralysis, inhibition of digestion, and nausea. If untreated leads to starvation and death. Another way to distinguish is that the stem of the wild sweet pea is mostly unbranched."

The actual book "Tanaina Plantlore (Kari 1987)" page 128 says

"The lateral veins of the leaflets of wild sweet pea are hidden, while those of the wild potato are conspicuous. Another way to distinguish between the two plants is that the stem of the wild sweet pea is mostly unbranched, while that of wild potato is definitely branched."

If your like me you can't help but want to see the actual source I went to my local library and searched for it. And here it is.
Picture
​Why was this plant ever thought to be toxic? Well in the report from Edward M. Treadwell and Thomas P. Clausen findings they went back into the deep archives to bring to light how this false conclusion ever got started in the first place in saying;

​"Statements of H. mackenziei’s toxicity can be traced back to a journal entry by Sir John Richardson of his exploration of the Alaskan interior in the early 1800’s. According to Richardson, H. mackenziei tubers were included in a stew for dinner one night, and the next morning the expedition was so ill that no progress could be made. A published version of this journal is available in University of Alaska’s Rasmunsen library (Houston 1984), and in it the incident is reported, as well as other episodes where the Richardson party included ledum and cranberries in their meals (both of which are known to cause sickness if consumed in large quantities). Even more disturbing, there are descriptions of the party feeding on lichens, leather, rotten meat, warble-fly dung, and fish entails dug up days after the original meal of fish. The party was not well-prepared for boreal exploration, and were often at the point of starvation, and thus any claim of “poisoning” by Richardson is circumspect, to say the least." (Is Hedysarum mackenziei (Wild Sweet Pea) Actually Toxic? by Edward M. Treadwell and Thomas P. Clausen 2008)

So there you have it people don't always believe what you see and hear let the research prove what is and what really isn't.
1 Comment
Avery B link
5/2/2021 10:22:44 am

This was lovely, thanks for sharing this

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Picture

    Author

    Avi Ben Shalom:

    ​When I was a young boy, I would gaze at my father with joy, to both learn from him, and become like him. He was indeed a real woodsman going out even for a whole month alone just to be in the wilderness. My fondest memories are of his taking me out into the woods all the time. When he died when I was eight, I had to learn that my life was going to continue being a it once was. Its hard when you have no one to teach you and you are forced to struggle and learn life skills alone. You begin to really feel the void of not having that mentor, that teacher you admire so much, one to lean on. But, I thank God for picking up the place where my father no longer could for truly its His guidance and wisdom and help that made me the Marine I became, the husband and father I am, and continue to seek to mature and grow better at being. As for me learning in such a difficult way I have sincerely seen how important it is to get help and guidance. And for this reason, I have made it my personal ambition to share what I have learned to help others who lack. I want to give what I have received to others because I know that wilderness knowledge, and bushcraft skills are not something any should ever feel they have to pay hundreds of dollars for just to learn those skills. I don't believe any person should be owing to anyone when it comes to the things pertaining to living and survival.   

    Archives

    May 2020
    April 2020
    November 2019
    September 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    January 2019

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

© 2018 Maccabbee Bushcraft & Outdoor Gear
We are a (USMC) veteran-owned, small business with a love for God, Country and the great outdoors!
  • Home
  • Sales
  • Products
    • Packs
    • Basecamp >
      • Sleep
      • Cordage
      • Camp Storage
    • Knives & Cutting Tools >
      • Axes
      • Saws
      • Wood Carving
      • Multi-Tool
    • Fire & Light >
      • Stoves
    • Coffee
    • Food & Cookware
    • Water & Hydration
    • Navigation
    • Rappelling
    • Hygiene
    • First Aid >
      • First Aid Video Resources
    • Foraging >
      • Herbal Courses
    • Off The Grid
    • Bushcraft Books/DVD's
    • Apparel
  • Bushcraft Education
    • Exploring The Grand Syllabus >
      • My Wilderness Experience Log Book
    • Why Write A Wilderness Experience Log Book
    • Bushcraft Tutorials >
      • Wood Working Tutorials
      • Navigation Tutorials
      • Foraging Tutorials
      • Cooking Tutorials
    • Fauna
    • Trees >
      • Food Sources
      • Medicinal Properties
      • Fuel/Construction
    • Wild Edibles >
      • Wild Edible List
      • Medicinal Plants >
        • Medicinal Blog
      • Edible Mushrooms
      • Mushroom Poisoning Facts
  • Blog
  • Policies
  • About Us
    • Contact